1 Comment
User's avatar
Andrew Brown's avatar

The argument that international humanitarian law can only be established by institutions which arise as a result of breaching these laws can be assimilated to a belief in progress, if you think that we learn from the past. Something like that is inherent in the grand narrative of Christianity: Christ is descended from both King David and from Cain, neither of whom were exactly Christlike.

But we, like Augustine, live in a time when progress is peeling away like soggy wallpaper, and all that still stands are the bricks of brute power. In such a world there are no crimes, only atrocities, some of which are also mistakes. It's hard to believe that there is any justification for history.

Expand full comment